Level 3 vs Comcast – explanation, comment, + links
As most are aware Level 3 has complained that it is being gouged by Comcast. It appears Comcast has demanded extra cash for transit costs due to an increased level of traffic due to Level 3’s new arrangement to carry Netflix traffic previously carried by Akamai. Under the Akamai CDN system Comcast had been paid to host Akamai servers on its network and there was obviously less load on their transit costs. No wonder they are unhappy.
Comcast, concerned about public opinion especially with the NBCU merger decision looming have made the following explanatory video:
However it’s difficult to see, at least in the mind of the general public, how this will help their case – the public is accustomed to paying for the bandwidth to receive content, not the other way round! While peering and simple Internet service are not the same thing, the difference is not easily discernible..
There are several illuminating explanations/comments on the web:
- 11/29 Leo Bicknell Re: Level 3 Communications Issues Statement Concerning Comcast’s Actions (peering ratios)
- 11/30 Leo Bicknell Re: Level 3 Communications Issues Statement Concerning Comcast’s Actions (breakdown of problem)
- 11/30 Leo Bicknell Re: Level 3 Communications Issues Statement Concerning Comcast’s Actions (NN & transparency in peering)
- 11/30 Richard A Steenbergen Re: TWT – Comcast congestion (Comcast screwing around w/ connections)
- 11/30 George Ou: Level 3 outbid Akamai on Netflix by reselling stolen bandwidth
- 11/30 Stacey Higginbotham A Play by Play on the Comcast and Level 3 Spat
- 11/30 Nate Anderson How Comcast became a toll-collecting, nuke-wielding hydra
- 11/30 Joe Waz Comcast’s Letter to FCC on Level 3
- 11/30 Paul Kouroupas Traffic Balance is not the Issue
- 12/01 Daniel Golding The Real Story Behind the Comcast-Level 3 Battle
- 12/01 Alex Goldman Comcast vs. Level 3: This Peering Dispute is About Content
- 12/02 Leo Bicknell The scale of streaming video on the Internet. (bandwidth requirement speculation)
- 12/02 Steve Schultze Trying to Make Sense of the Comcast / Level 3 Dispute
- 12/02 Adam Rothschild Peering Disputes: Comcast, Level 3, and You (includes informative graphic below)
- 12/02 Milton Mueller How to Discredit Net Neutrality
- 12/14 Corie Wright FCC filing (Free Press cites peering dispute as reason to oppose NBC-U merger)
- 12/15 Jeff Baumgartner Comcast: Level 3 Balks at Trial Offer
- 12/16 Level 3 FCC Filing (asking for peering conditions on NBC-U merger)
- 2/18 Janko Roettgers Netflix: Comcast Hates Us, Sort Of, Maybe (GigaOm)
Franck Martin 4:11 am on 12/01/2010 Permalink |
Waiting for the Dilbert cartoon…
joly 6:02 am on 03/26/2011 Permalink |
12/2 Public Knowledge explanatory video: